Breathing New Life into the Classics

The Song of Achilles

by Madeline Miller

The epic poems of Homer always bear retelling. Whether in the original format or recast in one of the many variations that have appeared over the centuries, these stories of kings, heroes, gods and goddesses have the power to stir the imagination.

Occasionally, a new version appears which turns convention completely on its head and treads a new, and sometimes controversial, path. One such is Madeline Miller’s prize-winning novel The Song of Achilles.


Miller’s work is an imaginative re-telling of The Iliad, Homer’s tale of the Trojan War. From first to last, she takes it, grapples with its metaphors and hidden meanings, and produces something refreshingly new. By choosing as her main protagonist and narrator Patroclus, one of the poet’s minor characters, she breathes new life into the original poetry.

Patroclus visits Sparta with his father as one of the many suitors to Helen. He is not much interested in marriage and is not too upset when Helen chooses Menelaus as her husband. On returning home, he has an angry fight with another boy, kills him, and as a result is exiled to Phthia, the country ruled by King Peleus, the father of Achilles.

The small, slight and untalented Patroclus forms an unlikely friendship with the handsome and strong demi-god, who takes him under his wing and allows him to share his lessons with the centaur Chiron. When Achilles is reluctantly drawn into Menelaus’ and Agamemnon’s war, despite the protestations of his mother, the Nereid Thetis, Patroclus accompanies him to Troy.

All of Homer’s imaginative narrative is there: the choice of Helen; her kidnap by Paris; the Greeks’ response; and finally the siege of Troy itself, Achilles’ defining battle with Hector and his ultimate death at the hands of Paris. However, the Achilles of The Song is not the macho hero of The Iliad. The friendship of the two boys develops into something quite different, a passionate love affair between two adult men. And Miller handles this with sympathy and flair. The characterisation in the novel is brilliant. The devious Odysseus, the arrogant Agamemnon and the learned centaur Chiron are portrayed with hyper-Homeric skill. Miller’s portrait of the nymph Thetis, rising almost vampire-like from the sea to confront her son’s lover made me shiver as I read.

And through it all moves a heroic, yet rather spoilt and petulant Achilles, fully aware what his fate will be but in the end carelessly embracing it for love’s sake. The end and the final reconciliation are clever and satisfying. Madeline Miller thoroughly deserved her 2012 Orange Prize for this debut novel.


[**PS This is a repost of a review I originally wrote a few years ago. Any readers interested can find a collection of my “old” reviews in a little book, available from Amazon, entitled Classic Reviews.

Best wishes!

Andrew G Lockhart       ]


3 thoughts on “Breathing New Life into the Classics

  1. andywinder

    Oh man, I haven’t read this book since high school but remember loving it. It really did capture the beauty and pain of the original myths while fleshing out the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus. This review made me want to read it again, so thanks for that! Are you familiar with any similar books about the classics/Greek mythology? I’ve wanted to read more books like this but haven’t been able to find one that’s as good.


    1. bookheathen

      Thank you for reading. I haven’t come across anything recently (maybe I haven’t been looking), but, going back a few decades, there were several great books by a writer called Mary Renault. Another writer who has dabbled is Margaret Atwood (The Penelopeiad). And Robert Graves (of I Claudius fame). I discussed these in my book It’s A Fantasy World, if you’re interested. No pressure! 🙂


  2. This sounds good and like something I would like to read! I like Chiron a lot, I was born in December so he was the inspiration for my astrological sign apparently…and who doesn’t like Greek mythology.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s